Article
Scoring Lung Lesions in Pigs: Choosing Practical Methods for CVPC and Pleurisy
A lung lesion score is useful only when it captures the extent of disease consistently. In pig production, veterinarians may need to assess cranioventral pulmonary consolidation (CVPC) and pleurisy under very different conditions, ranging from rapid slaughter-line inspection to detailed evaluation of collected lung samples. The scoring method must therefore match the purpose and available assessment time.
Most established systems rely on visual and manual estimation of the affected lung surface or volume[1].
Scoring CVPC: Surface Area or Lung Volume?
Several systems estimate the percentage of lung surface affected by consolidation, using a two-dimensional approach. Others assess affected lung volume or weight, providing a three-dimensional estimate[1],[2].
Importantly, these methods are not necessarily interchangeable in their practical application. Hannan et al.'s system, for example, was designed for detailed assessment under experimental conditions. It uses a score from 0, indicating no lesions, to 35, indicating involvement of all lung tissue. Lesions are first drawn onto a standard lung diagram before the overall score is calculated[1].
By contrast, methods developed for field conditions may be more suitable when rapid assessment is required. Garcia-Morante et al. reported high correlations between different scoring systems, while Sitjar et al. found that superficial and volumetric measurement techniques provided essentially identical information[1],[2].
Scoring Pleurisy: Different Systems, Different Objectives[1]
Pleurisy scoring systems also vary in their classification criteria.
The Madec and Kobisch system uses scores from 0 to 4, distinguishing absent pleurisy, interlobular adhesions, small localised lesions, extensive adhesions and partial or total ribcage condemnation. Its higher score identifies advanced lesions with potential performance or carcass consequences.
The CTPA system is simpler, using scores from 0 to 2 for absent, fibrinous and extended pleurisy. However, mild chronic lesions with limited adhesions may not fit clearly into either of its two positive categories.
Pointon et al.'s system distinguishes adhesions between lung lobes from adhesions between the lungs and chest wall. It also records whether pneumonia accompanies pleurisy. The Italian SPES system, meanwhile, considers lesion location and extent, particularly in the diaphragmatic lobes.
Can Digital Assessment Improve Consistency?
Manual scoring remains vulnerable to differences between assessors and the speed of slaughter-line operations. Image-based assessment and artificial intelligence offer possible alternatives. Trachtman et al. reported 86% overall accuracy in differentiating pleural surfaces affected by pleurisy from healthy surfaces[3].
However, further development is needed before such systems can be implemented reliably in high-capacity slaughterhouses.
Clinical Bottom Line
The scoring system should be selected according to the lesion, assessment objective and available time. Training, consistent criteria and appropriate recording methods are essential to make results comparable across farms and batches.
References:
- Maes D, Sibila M, Pieters M, Haesebrouck F, Segalés J, de Oliveira LG. Review on the methodology to assess respiratory tract lesions in pigs and their production impact. Veterinary research. 2023 Feb 1;54(1):8. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1186/s13567-023-01136-2.pdf
- Sibila M, Aragón V, Fraile L, Segalés J. Comparison of four lung scoring systems for the assessment of the pathological outcomes derived from Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae experimental infections. BMC veterinary research. 2014 Jul 19;10(1):165. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1186/1746-6148-10-165.pdf
- Trachtman AR, Bergamini L, Palazzi A, Porrello A, Capobianco Dondona A, Del Negro E, Paolini A, Vignola G, Calderara S, Marruchella G. Scoring pleurisy in slaughtered pigs using convolutional neural networks. Veterinary research. 2020 Apr 10;51(1):51. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1186/s13567-020-00775-z.pdf
Related Contents
Article
Multifactorial Causes of Gout in Poultry: Identifying Nutritional, Infectious and Management-Related Risk Factors
Gout in poultry is often associated with excessive dietary calcium or protein. However, attributing...
Article
Visceral vs Articular Gout in Chickens: Differentiating Clinical Presentation and Pathological Lesions
A chicken with swollen joints and difficulty walking may present a very different clinical picture f...
Article
Clinical Pathology and Postmortem Diagnosis of Gout in Chickens
A chicken may show only dullness, reduced feed intake and dehydration before developing severe syste...
Article
Slaughterhouse Lung Examination in Pigs: Detecting Subclinical Respiratory Disease
A batch of pigs may reach slaughter weight without showing obvious respiratory signs, yet examinatio...
Article
Cranioventral Pulmonary Consolidation in Pigs: Pathological Features and Clinical Significance
A pig may show reduced growth performance without displaying prominent respiratory signs. At slaught...
Article
Pleurisy in Pigs: Lesion Development, Pathogen Associations and Clinical Interpretation
Pleural adhesions in slaughter pigs can indicate respiratory disease that occurred weeks before the...
Article
Recognising Urinary Bladder Rupture in Buffalo Calves with Obstructive Urolithiasis
A buffalo calf presenting with abdominal distension, anorexia and repeated attempts to urinate may h...
Article
Tube Cystostomy for Obstructive Urolithiasis in Buffalo Calves: Surgical Management and Recovery
Obstructive urolithiasis complicated by urinary bladder rupture requires surgical intervention to re...